The brand new disclosure perspective additionally the general meaning of which verse try maybe not, although not, associated with the matter-of matrimony in order to low-Muslims. The classical interpretation states that the verse is shown whenever a couple of polytheist men from Quraish wanted their siblings is right back, Oum Kelthoum and you can Bint Aqabah, once they had changed into Islam and you will moved to help you Medina within the acquisition to participate the Muslim community.
Which general suggestion isn’t necessarily correct together with “strength” and/or “weakness” of your own spiritual religion isn’t associated with the intercourse however, alternatively into man or woman’s identification and you will character
It’s worthy of reminding that the Prophet signed at the time a binding agreement called Al-Hudaybya Treaty into contrary tribe regarding Quraish to stop the brand new combat having a decade. It agreement specified, yet others fitness singles, that any Quraychit girl who would get in on the Prophet when you look at the Medina with no consent out-of the girl legal tutor might be delivered back in order to Mecca.
Oum Kelthoum, who was simply the only one to alter so you’re able to Islam inside her relatives, and you can who fled from a single of the very hostile surroundings, begged this new Prophet to not ever repatriate the woman so you can this lady tribe therefore because to not be open once more on their unjust procedures.
The fresh verse above mentioned was then found to quit the newest extradition of females which transformed into Islam and steer clear of brand new revenge regarding their particular families. For this reason, the brand new Prophet refused to posting straight back the exiled female on enemies, since the agreement is actually was able for males.
The rationale of the verse previously mentioned shows that it can perhaps not tackle at all the wedding so you’re able to low-Muslims, however, was as an alternative found to fulfill specific strategic standards off protecting women that changed into Islam resistant to the commonly of their family unit members and you will just who willingly requested this new Prophet’s coverage.
Brand new paradox that people emphasize within these traditional interpretations questions the newest undeniable fact that based on such students, Muslim ladies are banned so you can wed “disbelievers” including Christian and you may Jewish men, if you are to your question of Muslim boys, Religious and you will Jewish ladies are thought to be believers. How do we believe, in identical Religious or Jewish society, one the male is disbelievers if you are women of the same organizations try believers?
In the absence of people facts that warrants new prohibition regarding the wedding regarding Muslim people into followers out-of almost every other monotheistic religions, the brand new latest scholars justify their perceptions from the “the newest pure tiredness” out-of Muslim women who might go astray in “bad” determine of the Christian otherwise Jewish husbands. Although Muslim man might possibly dominate their Religious or Jewish spouse and you can manage his kid’s and you may very own believe.
This new Qur’anic verse, tackling the wedding out of Muslim men or women so you can believers regarding other religions, place specific laws and regulations using an enthusiastic egalitarian code
In fact, new disagreement is not persuading since if this new told you verse forbids the wedding between a good Muslim girl and you will a Christian or Jewish child as it’s unanimously interpreted now, very including relationship is even forbidden to the Muslim kid. Still, centered on certain Qur’anic passages while the Islamic stability, Christians and you can Jews are considered unanimously because the believers belonging to religions found because of the Allah whatever the present differences in terms of the fresh new dogma together with theological beliefs.
Because of this, the study of verse shows that the newest Qur’an prohibits the brand new relationship away from one another Muslim individuals to polytheists.
But it’s worth bringing-up you to scholars agree unanimously towards ban of the matrimony from an excellent Muslim woman in order to a great Jewish or Christian, while zero the main Qur’an provides for for example ban one to justifies which discrimination.